Would you trust a live mix more if you knew it was automated?

I saw this bit about people preferring AI stories when they thought they were human. Honestly, I'm not surprised — it's all about the framing. But I'm more curious about the flip side: when do you actually prefer the human imperfection? Like, in a live mix, I'd rather hear a fader settle a beat late than a perfect auto-tuned crowd. Anyone else feel that way?